# The Bicycle as a System

### Purpose

To explore the nature of systems by examining the systems that make a bicycle work. Students will begin to understand how the different systems of a bicycle relate to each other and be able to identify the properties of each part or subsystem.

### Context

This lesson gives students an opportunity to examine the nature of systems in the context of an object with which they are very familiar – the bicycle. While this lesson is intended for grades 6-8, it presents concepts that are more appropriate for 7th and 8th grade students.

The main goal of having students learn about systems is not to have them talk about systems in abstract terms, but to enhance their ability (and inclination) to identify the various aspects of systems in attempting to understand the whole system. Examining systems is really a way of thinking rather than theories or discoveries.

Students will identify the properties of the various subsystems of a bicycle and examine how they relate to the whole. According to research: “Children tend to think of the properties of a system as belonging to individual parts of it rather than as arising from the interaction of the parts. A system property that arises from interaction of parts is therefore a difficult idea.” (Benchmarks for Science Literacy, p. 262.)

Students should already know that if something consists of many parts, the parts usually influence one another. Also they should be aware that something may not work as well (or at all) if a part of it is missing, broken, worn out, mismatched, or misconnected.

It is important to establish the boundary of the system to include enough parts so that their relationship to one another makes sense. Drawing the boundary of a system well can make the difference between understanding and not understanding what is going on. Thinking of everything within some boundary as being a system suggests the need to look for certain kinds of influence and behavior. For example, students should consider a system’s inputs and outputs-the outputs of some parts being inputs for others.

Systems are not mutually exclusive. Systems may be so closely related that there is no way to draw boundaries that separate all parts of one from all parts of the other. Any part of a system may itself be considered as a system-a subsystem-with its own internal parts and interactions. Any system is likely to be part of a larger system that it influences and that influences it. The idea of a system should be expanded to include connections among systems.

Students will also learn about the choices and constraints that go into the design of a bicycle system. Depending on whether the bicycle is intended for racing, mountain roads, or touring, influences its design and such choices as the type of tires, frame and materials, and drives and gears. In addition, accommodating one constraint can often lead to conflict with others. For example, the lightest material may not be the strongest, or the most efficient shape may not be the safest or the most aesthetically pleasing. Therefore, every design problem lends itself to many alternative solutions, depending on what values people place on the various constraints.

### Motivation

Before reading the article Bicycle Heroes, on the Franklin Institute website, discuss with students their personal experience and knowledge of bicycles.

• Describe how a bicycle works.
• Has your bicycle ever broken? What part broke? Were you able to repair it?

Distribute the article Bicycle Heroes or students can use their Bicycle as a System student esheet to read it online. The article describes one of the earliest bicycles, how it worked, and the design changes that improved its use. It also discusses the early bicycle clubs, as well as the first bicycle racers who became stars and who helped to popularize the sport. In addition, the article has several photographs of these early bicycles.

After reviewing the article, ask students:

• How do the early bicycles differ from bicycles made today?
• What accounted for the popularity of bicycles when they were first invented in the late 1800s?
• What accounts for the popularity of bicycles today?
• Identify the various parts of the bicycle.
• What does each part do? Describe some of the properties of these parts.
• What is the purpose of a bicycle system?

• In your opinion, list in order of importance the following bicycle characteristics: speed, safety, comfort, durability. Explain your choice.
• How might a bicycle’s design differ depending on which characteristic is more important?
• Is it possible to accommodate all four characteristics in designing a bicycle?

### Development

Divide students into six groups. Explain to the groups that they will conduct an Internet exploration to understand more about the parts of a bicycle and how bicycle systems work.

Students should use their student esheet to review Science of Cycling on The Exploratorium website. Ask each group to select one subsystem to explore. Students should review their section and describe the subsystem and the parts that make a bicycle work.

The subsystems are:

• The Wheel
• Drivers & Gears
• Frames & Materials
• Brakes & Steering
• Aerodynamics
• Human Power

Note: The Introduction section discusses the people who were interviewed and provided information for the website. It is not necessary for students to read the Introduction to understand the lesson.

Distribute the student sheet entitled The Bicycle as a System. As students read about each subsystem, they should use their worksheet to list the parts of the subsystem, define the properties it has on its own, and how it works with the whole system. To answer the questions, students may need to use their knowledge about the other bicycle subsystems that are described on the site.

Ask the students to present their findings to the class. At appropriate times during the presentations, lead the discussion to help the rest of the class process the information.

• What is the boundary of the bicycle system? (For the purpose of this lesson, it includes all the bicycle’s subsystems, as well as the person riding the bicycle.)
• How is the bicycle system related to other larger systems? (It can be related to road, air currents, and weather systems.)
• The seat is one part of the bicycle. Use three different words or phrases that describe the seat. Do any of these words or phrases also describe the whole bicycle? (Possible answers include: soft, hard, smooth, narrow, uncomfortable. These could also describe the bicycle as a whole.)
• What parts of the bicycle must work together if you want to ride around a corner? (Wheels, frame, steering, and human power all work together to ride the bicycle around a corner.)
• How would the functioning of the bicycle change if one part or subsystem wears out?(The bicycle would be more difficult or impossible to ride.)

### Assessment

Assess students’ understanding based on how well they have answered the questions about the bicycle as a system. Students should demonstrate an understanding that all the subsystems need to work together for the bicycle to function.

Students should be able to identify approximately six parts for each subsystem they explored, including each part’s function, as well as the input and output for the subsystem.

Students should acknowledge that all bicycles have similar subsystems and it is possible to place the same part from one bicycle in another bicycle. Variations to the bicycle, in terms of materials or the arrangement of parts, may affect the bicycle’s speed, safety, comfort, or durability. It is even possible that the variations would cause the bicycle not to function.

### Extensions

Bike Science: How Bikes Works is a good site that explores the science of bicycles. Students can use this resources to learn more about bicycle physics.